Arden pounds on Kit's chest to resuscitate him, and wakes him. The doctor lies to him, though, claiming there was no visitation. He examines Grace, who has been healed of her bullet wounds. He interrogates Pepper, who has been charged with Grace's protection. Pepper says that Grace's womb has been protected from his examinations. Pepper also reveals to him that she was framed for drowning and mutilating her baby nephew before her incarceration. Pepper explains to Arden that, because she looks like a "freak", she was locked up forever. She has been given significant intelligence by the beings that laugh at Arden's feeble experiments.
Sister Mary Eunice announces a change in the common room and presents a new jukebox to replace the Dominique record. She plays "I Put A Spell on You" as a tribute to Briarcliff's newest prisoner, Judy Martin. Lana tries to talk to Kit, but Thredson enters the common room and sits with them. Thredson reveals the failed abortion to Kit, and a plan to keep Lana and Kit imprisoned. Thredson has been hired full time as a therapist after Sr. Mary Eunice found and released him.
Lana is restrained by Carl and a guard from attacking Sr. Mary Eunice, who is conducting a room search. They haul Lana off to hydrotherapy, while Sr. Mary Eunice finds a cucumber in Judy's room. The nun orders and administers electroshock therapy. Sr. Mary Eunice intentionally and sadistically adds extra current against Arden's orders.
Sr. Mary Eunice tends to Msgr. Howard's wounds and he surprises her by attempting an exorcism. She manages to stop him, and she retaliates by raping him. Msgr. Howard reiterates his vow of celibacy as she pins him to the bed. She takes his virginity as a disgusted Arden watches from the doorway.
Judy distractedly enters the common room, observed by Lana and Kit. Jude tries to destroy the new jukebox but is stopped by Lana. This prompts Judy to hallucinate a choreography of "The Name Game" with the common room residents.
Arden's afternoon feeding of the creatures is crashed by Sr. Mary Eunice. He is repulsed by her actions. She wants to lobotomize Judy, and he refuses "because she wishes it". He kills the creatures with a revolver, saying the experiment is over. He tries to shoot himself in the head but falters. Sr. Mary Eunice calls him pitiful and walks away.
Msgr. Howard dismisses everyone making bread in the kitchen except Judy, whom he still calls Jude. She notices his crucifixion wounds, even through her impaired mental faculty. He admits that he failed in his exorcism and laments that Sr. Jude was right. He tries to get through to her for counsel and stirs feelings and memories in her. She responds with the advice to "kill her" (Sr. Mary Eunice).
Carl leads Thredson to Arden's office, where Thredson searches for sodium pentothal. He discovers Grace, giving birth, midwifed by Pepper.
Msgr. Howard prays, where he is discovered by the possessed nun. She offers round two, but she realizes that he is trying for strength to kill her. She wonders aloud how he will kill her, which instead entices her. She intends to propel him towards papacy, appealing to his ambitions for power. He reiterates his intent to return her host to a state of grace, which angers the nun to the point of loss of control and the host emerges. He takes the opportunity to throw her from the balcony at the top of the staircase. When she falls and hits the floor below, Shachath kisses her.
Msgr. Howard gives last rites to Sister Mary. Arden tells the Monsignor that she needs to be cremated and insists on doing it himself.
Carl brings Kit for his session with Thredson; Grace and the baby are in Thredson's office. Thredson does not know about the alien intervention. Thredson searches for the confession tape, but Lana has hidden it and uses it as blackmail against him.
Judy continues to try and recognize the names of patients. She recognizes Mother Claudia, to whom Judy babbles about Mary Eunice and Rome, including the seduction. Judy tells Mother Superior that Lana doesn't belong there and that she is falsely imprisoned. She bids the nun to help her.
In the crematory, Arden stands before where Mary Eunice's body lies and strokes her hair. He then commits suicide by climbing onto the tray with her and incinerating himself along with her body.
- Pepper to Arthur Arden: "You think you're like [the Extraterrestrials] with your clumsy experiments, but they laugh at you, Dr. Arden...they make jokes. Here's a good one, 'Knock knock. Who's there? Arden. Arden who? Arden't you the quack? Who'd make a better duck?"
- Kit to Oliver Thredson: "You are one sick twist!"
- Lana Winters to Oliver Thredson: "I don't wanna ruin it for you, but Spot jumps."
- Arthur Arden to Sister Mary Eunice: "You have no idea what it means to have lost you."
- Sister Mary Eunice to Timothy Howard: "There was a priest, the dirty beast, whose name was Alexander. His mighty dick was inches thick, he called it Salamander. Is yours inches thick father?"