Sophie, along with her friends, Todd and Milo, were viewers of the original My Roanoke Nightmare documentary. They became such fans of the series that the three of them decided to organize an expedition to the site, using helmet-mounted cameras to record their trek.
Personality and Appearance
Although appearing to be a very stereotypical like-hungry person from the 21st century, she is actually nice and intelligent. She also cares for other people's safety, even when she doesn't know them. Her hair and eyes are brown and she is caucasian. She has been seen wearing very casual and comfortable clothing.
The friends are making their way through the wilderness surrounding the property when they come across a disorientated woman limping through the brush. Obviously injured and afraid, the woman flees and the kids give chase. They lose sight of her, but during her pursuit Sophie discovers the scene of a recent car crash. The accident had been so severe that the vehicle had rolled over onto its roof, and she kneels down to take a closer look. Sophie recoils in horror and their helmet-mounted cameras display the body of Diana Cross beneath the wreckage.
Sophie, Todd, and Milo go to the police in order to report what they saw. Of course, the police thought the three were pranking them and ordered them not to go near the property again. The trio ignore the police and decide to investigate the house, but once it becomes night, Sophie and her friends feel uneasy. Eventually, they find Lee, who has been possessed by Scathach. Lee murders Todd which causes Sophie and Milo to panic and flee to the editing trailer. It's there that they find out everyone involved with Return to Roanoke has died, except for Monet, Audrey and of course, Lee. Sophie suggests they fight Lee, who is marching to the house to kill Monet and Audrey, and eventually convinces Milo to venture out of the trailer and help the duo. Both end up being found by the colonists where they are forced onto stakes and get burned alive.
- Sophie is the third character in American Horror Story portrayed by Taissa Farmiga, the others being Violet Harmon and Zoe Benson in Murder House and Coven respectively.
- Sophie is the first of Taissa Farmiga's characters not to have a relationship with a character played by Evan Peters.
- To Todd Allan Connors and Milo regarding My Roanoke Nightmare: "On the surface, it's an interracial story set in a post-racial world. Which, of course, is a lie. But they're really talking about the colonization of America. The Butcher and the Roanoke Colony. Which became a matriarchy in a patriarchal system. That's why it's so timely. It's a battle we're fighting today."
- Sophie: "This is Sophie Green, and I'm here to bear witness to the evil that is happening out here. I'm in the woods near the house of My Roanoke Nightmare in eastern North Carolina. It's all real. There's people dead everywhere. Lee Harris is a murderer. She-she she just killed my friend, Todd Connor, with a cleaver. And she's on her way to kill Audrey Tindall and Monet Tumusiime right now. They're in the house and they're in danger. We called the police but they won't listen."