|Season 1, Episode 3|
|Air date||October 19, 2011|
|Directed by||Bradley Buecker|
|"Murder House" on IMDB|
"Halloween: Part 1"
After putting the house back on the market, Vivien learns about its first residents. Ben's visitor causes him to further unravel. Constance and Moira's history is revealed.
The young Moira is seen cleaning the bedroom of the house. A drunken man enters the room and gropes her. After resisting his advances, he continues to bribe her with the offer of a car. She continues to deny him, and he advances on her, pinning her to the bed and raping her. Constance enters the room, catching them. She draws a gun and shoots a warning shot through the window. Then shoots Moira through her eye (this is the reason why her eye is now clouded). Constance turns to the man, exclaiming "I've loved you since I was sixteen" (revealing the man is her husband, Hugo) and then shoots him three times in the chest. Grief stricken, Constance sits on the bed next to her husband's body sobbing.
Ben and Vivien are arguing. It is implied that they are arguing about his meetings with Hayden McClaine, but instead it is about finances. All of their investments are tied up, and they are unable to move out of the house until it is sold. They agree to rent an apartment, but Ben must continue to see his clients at the house.
Vivien has tea with Marcy, the realtor who sold them the house. Marcy tells Vivien stories of the former owners, and alludes to the fireplace poker being used in their sexual habits. Vivien interjects that they need to put the house on the market, and sell it without a fiscal loss. Marcy debates the possibility of this, given the market. Vivien counters that Marcy should have told them more about the history of the house, but Marcy defends that she was under no legal obligations to reveal any more information about deaths on premises longer than the last three years. Vivien claims she will blackmail Marcy for "extreme criminal negligence" if she does not try to sell the house.
In another room, Constance is once again caught stealing silverware by Moira. Moira clearly hates Constance, but Constance rebukes her for being a terrible maid and a thief of "biblical proportions" (alluding to Moira's affair with Constance's husband). Constance intends that Moira will eventually be accused of stealing the Harmon's things and that they will fire her. Moira breaks down, furious with Constance and frustrated that she is bound to the house and unable to move on. Constance retorts repeatedly that Moira put herself in that situation.
Ben's new patient is Sally Freeman, a woman who is approaching divorce, her husband leaving her because he feels she is boring despite her best efforts. Ben is distracted, and zones out during the session. He regains consciousness in the backyard, with bloody hands, standing on a patch of worn earth. He washes the blood from his hands and enters to see Moira sponging blood off the hallway floor. She claims to have not seen anything. She has already cleaned his office, ready for his next patient. Ben is missing his digital recorder of the session with Sally Freeman. He becomes frantic to find it and discover what happened. Moira once again distracts him, trying to seduce him. As she becomes increasingly aggressive, Ben has had enough. He grabs her and loudly yells that she is fired. Vivien walks in, perplexed by Ben's yelling.
In the kitchen, Ben defends his case for firing Moira, saying that her continued attempts at seduction are unacceptable. Vivien (who, of course, perceives Moira as an older woman) is shocked and confused. Subtly, Moira explains that while men objectify women and see "what they want to see", women instead see into the "soul of a person". Moira is willing to forget the incident and go on with her job. Vivien appears to be a word away from firing her, but Moira bites back, saying that she deserves respect and not to be tossed away like trash and that she will press charges if Ben "lays a hand" on her again or tries to fire her without just cause. Ben tries to press the point with Vivien, but as they unknowingly see the situation very differently, Vivien instead thinks that Ben's indiscretion has left him very "screwed up", paranoid and guilty. She wants to avoid any additional lawsuits from Moira as they try to leave the house.
Outside, Vivien is cutting the rose bushes when she hears the tour guide for the Eternal Darkness Tour, announcing her house as "the jewel of Midtown: Murder House!"
Ben finds Violet smoking. Despite her concealment, he knows and claims he is not there to bust her. He is going easy on her due to her recent trauma during the home invasion. He offers to find her a therapist if she wants to discuss the incident. As he walks away, Tate, who was hiding behind a pillar, emerges. He tells her she is lucky to have a dad that cares.
Ben once again confronts Moira about his missing tape recorder. She claims it "might be down the front of my dress". She says its absence is hopefully not a problem, as his next patient is in his office.
Confused since he has no other patients scheduled, he goes to his office. The unexpected visitor is Hayden. She tells Ben that she did not have the abortion and is instead moving to Los Angeles and demands financial support for their alleged baby. She also wants active participation from Ben. The conversation is cut short by detective, Jack Colquitt, at the door. Hayden leaves, making plans to meet up with Ben the next day. Ben thinks the detective is there because of the home invasion, but he is from the Missing Persons Division and is there regarding Sally Freeman. Her husband has reported that she did not return home, leaving Ben the last to have seen her. Colquitt scoffs after seeing Moira (obviously as Ben does) and asks, "How do you get anything done with her around?"
The tour concludes with the Murder House. Vivien is revealed to be attending the tour, and she listens to a history unknown to her about her own home.
Stan relays that in 1922, Charles Montgomery was a surgeon who grafted different pieces from separate species onto each other. He also had a terrible addiction to ether. His Philadelphian socialite wife, Nora, was disappointed by the austerity they must practice from his lack of funds. In 1925, their son cries as they eat dinner and argue, and Nora orders Daphne, their servant, to remove the child. Nora states that bill collectors have come once again and she will have none of it. She demands that Charles see a young starlet who is pregnant, Dorothy Hudson, and perform an abortion on her. Dorothy gives Nora $60, and Nora drugs her and ushers her into the basement. He performs at least two dozen other illegal abortions by 1926.
Stan is about to describe the "grand finale" of 1926, but Vivien, seeing blood on her pants, runs to the house interrupting the tour.
At the doctor's office, Ben and Vivien are told that the blood is benign spotting, and that it is not a miscarriage. Stress is potentially dangerous to the pregnancy, and the doctor chastises them for thinking about moving during Vivien's pregnancy, as it is "one of the most stressful times" in a person's life. Ben is suddenly overcome by flashes back to his affair with Hayden and passes out.
Constance is walking a dog and waves to Tate, who is standing in a window of the house. Tate does not acknowledge her, which leaves her confused. Observing this while putting the "For Sale" sign back up, Marcy is perplexed as well, as she did not see Tate at all. Constance makes a snide remark to Marcy, saying "Good luck selling this lemon."
Ben is jogging, and encounters Larry. Larry needs $1000 for headshots, but Ben refuses.
Ben tears his office apart, looking for the recorder, and blacks out again. This time, he is awoken by Constance, lying in the same spot in the yard as before, again with a shovel. He begins digging up the spot where he has awoken several times. Constance claims that the soil will not support plants due to pesticides and suggests he build a gazebo and patio instead. Moira watches anxiously from above.
Vivien is examining classified ads for a new apartment when the doorbell rings. Wary, given the home invasion, Vivien approaches the door. Peering through the peephole, she sees Nora, who claims she has an appointment to look at the house. With a candlestick (as a potential weapon) behind her back, Vivien lets her in. Nora marvels at the wood and glass fixtures, which have been restored to their original grandeur (being how they were when she lived in the house). Upon entering the kitchen, Nora is horrified at the modern appliances. Vivien mentions that she is pregnant, which piques Nora's interest. Vivien asks Nora if she would like tea, and Nora accepts. As Vivien turns around to retrieve the tea she was preparing, she finds Nora has vanished.
The detective returns to tell Ben that they have found his missing patient Sally Freeman. She had overdosed (in a suicide attempt) and put herself into a coma without identification. She had Ben's recorder on her, and the details from Ben's blackout during the session are played. Sally was uncharacteristically violent, trying to get Ben's attention, and slashed her wrists with his letter opener. The detective thinks Ben's lack of action made him culpable, if not legally accountable, for the crime.
Vivien and Violet tour an apartment for rent. Violet accuses her parents of running away from their problems rather than facing them, and thinks the house is a source of strength.
Ben receives a call from Vivien's doctor (she tested his blood after he passed out in her office). His blood shows traces that he's been drugged with Laudanum, an archaic compound which causes memory loss. He realizes Moira has been spiking his drinks with it. Moira tells him to "prove it" when he confronts her. Hayden shows up at the door, having been stood up during the course of the days events. She is furious, wanting to tell everything to Vivien, who is not yet back home. Ben talks her down from her outburst, and she agrees to leave. As she exits, an unseen Larry hits her over the head with a shovel. Ben goes into hysterics, asking Larry what he has done, and Larry explains that he was trying to save Ben from having to kill her himself, as it would have been the only way to solve his problems. Larry convinces Ben not to call the police, and that he will take care of the body. Larry notices the hole that Ben has been digging and digs deeper as Ben recovers. At the bottom of the hole are Moira's remains. Larry drags Hayden's corpse on top and fills the hole.
Later, Ben takes Constance's advice to cover the hole with a gazebo. Watching upstairs with a horrified Moira, Constance tells her "Poor girl, now you're stuck here forever." Ben and Vivien enjoy the completed gazebo, drinks in hand, though Vivien has no knowledge of the two corpses buried beneath it.
That night as Vivien sleeps, Nora pays her a visit, hovering her hand over Vivien's stomach.
Featured Characters Edit
Sally Freeman Edit
|Portrayed by||Adina Porter|
|Occupation||housewife / Ben's patient|
Sally Freeman is a one of Ben's patients. She is seeing him because she is desperately trying to save her marriage. Her husband claims she is too boring. During a session, Ben blacks out and Sally is gone, as is his audio recording of the session. Sally's disappearance begins an investigation, assigned to Jack Colquitt. Sally is revealed to have attempted suicide (as she slit her wrist, desperate to get the attention of a bored Ben) and entered a coma, though she is alive.
Dorothy Hudson Edit
|Portrayed by||Abbie Cobb|
Dorothy Hudson is Charles' first abortion patient. She is a young starlet aspiring to fame, who got unintentionally pregnant.
Jack Colquitt Edit
|Portrayed by||Geoffrey Rivas|
|First Appearance||Murder House|
|Last Appearance||Spooky Little Girl|
|Occupation||Detective (Missing Persons division)|
Colquitt is a detective for the Los Angeles Police Department, assigned to the Missing Persons division. He investigated the disappearance of Sally Freeman. He interviewed Ben, determining that Ben was the last to see her prior to her disappearance. He returned Ben's audio recorder after Freeman was discovered.
- Jack Colquitt returns in the episode "Spooky Little Girl" with Hayden's sister Marla, who is looking for Hayden.
- Jack Colquitt is a reference to The X-Files. Take a Chance: A Jack Colquitt Adventure was the name of a novel written by the Cigarette Smoking Man on The X-Files. "American Horror Story" producer James Wong directed that episode of The X-Files. He also introduced a character named "Jack Colquitt" to another series he developed for Fox, as a signature. 
Guest Stars Edit
- Kate Mara as Hayden McClaine
- Frances Conroy as Moira O'Hara
- Alexandra Breckenridge as Young Moira O'Hara
- Lily Rabe as Nora Montgomery
- Matt Ross as Charles Montgomery
- Christine Estabrook as Marcy
- Geoffrey Rivas as Detective Jack Colquitt
- Adina Porter as Sally Freeman
- David Anthony Higgins as Stan
- Eve Gordon as Dr. Hall
- Eric Close as Hugo
- Abbie Cobb as Dorothy Hudson
- Constance (to Hugo, after catching him with his pants down): "I've loved you since I was sixteen."
- Hugo (to Constance, after raping Moira): "Sweetheart, please, this didn't mean anything!"
- Constance (to Hugo, as she shoots him in the heart): "You broke my heart for the last time."
- Vivien (to Ben, after their financial argument): "Don't lie to me again. If you lie to me again, we're through."
- Constance (to Moira): "Until I get a full set. Then it's off to eBay, where I'll make a pretty penny and you'll be accused of theft. You are a thief of Biblical proportions, after all, your specialty being weak husbands."
- Moira (to Constance): "I don't want to be here anymore! I'm frightened! I miss my mother!"
- Hugo (to Moira): "Why? It's a shame to waste such a beautiful bed."
- Constance (to Moira): "You think I wanna stay? In this world of death and rot and regret? Try to find some dignity in the situation. Move on, missy!"
- Constance (to Moira): "Every time I find my heart breaking just a sliver for you, I suddenly remember, you made this mess for yourself. And, I also remember, every time I see that ghostly eye, that I was and continue to be a hell of shot."
- Moira (to Constance): "You need to pay for what you've done."
Constance (to Moira): "Oh, I do. Every goddamn day."
- Vivien (to Ben): "We were just getting it back, Ben."
- Moira (to Constance): "Adding those to your magpie stash?"
- After shooting Moira and Hugo, Constance removes her earrings. This room is the same one from which Moira caught her stealing earrings from Vivien's collection in Pilot.
- Moira explains that while men objectify women and see what they want to see, women instead see into the soul of a person. This explains why Ben (and presumably any other man, including the detective) sees the young Moira, and women see the older version.
- This episode promulgates a longstanding but unfounded urban legend that the actor Sal Mineo was killed by a man he had tried to pick up for sex. In fact, the man who confessed to and was tried and convicted for stabbing Mineo had been a pizza deliveryman who killed Mineo while trying to rob him. The actual murderer had no idea who Mineo was, either in short-term sexual encounter sense or in a larger awareness of his celebrity. Also, Mineo was only stabbed once (not multiple times as shown in this episode), though the stab was in his heart.
- ↑ The year is not shown in the episode "Murder House", but in the Threads of Horror video
- ↑ Jensen, Jeff, "The Murder House Rules", 20 Oct 2011